Compensation in the Lean Enterprise

July 3, 2017

Below is an interesting question that many companies struggle with their efforts to motivate and provide incentives for their employees.

The Question 

We have implemented the Lean principals in our Manufacturing area and are now set up in cells, but we have come across a problem with compensation.  Presently we pay for job worth as determined by salary surveys and internal evaluation methods.  But our manufacturing workers are no longer doing only one job.  We don't want to go to complicated skills based pay system either.  Can anyone share what they have done?”

The Answer

If I understood the question correctly, it may be time to reconsider variable compensation based on individual performance.

As you correctly note, a complicated skills based system takes a lot of energy and may not be worth it (unless you are using it to drive cross-training and flexibility).  A number of companies I have worked with have taken different approaches to this problem.  Those that seem most successful have taken two approaches:

One is a “Scanlon System” type approach where detailed performance (and profit) details are shared and compensation beyond a reasonable base level is dependant on performance and is shared equitably with ALL of the employees.  Assuming the base pay level handles differentials in skill sets and responsibilities this seems to work well.

The other approach breaks the additional compensation for performance into team areas – so if this team performs well they all share equitably in the results.  This works pretty well for the group but can have the unintended consequence of causing teams to compete against one another for resources and (gasp!) not be focused on the customer.

Each of the above has plusses and minuses.

We need to remember that Deming (and others) were/are against the idea of subjective appraisal systems.  I suggest you get a copy of “Punished by Rewards” by Alphie Kohn.  This is the best work I have seen to date that examines human motivation in the workplace, classroom and dinner table.  It contains exhaustive references to other works and studies for more information.  Even though there is little in Alphie’s book directly tied to manufacturing and Lean, he does heavily refer to Deming and others.

Basically, he does a good job of helping us understand and differentiate between extrinsic and intrinsic motivators.  Extrinsic motivators can be (all too often) only forms of manipulation – do this and you get that.  Intrinsic motivators come from enjoying the work through, among other things, having a say in the work and how it is done (an underpinning of Lean teams).

The takeaway is this – pay does not make the top five in most satisfaction surveys.  Make sure the pay is fair.  If bonuses or variable compensation are going to be used, it must be done so that it is perceived to be even-handed and not subject to capricious, subjective “appraisal” results.  Then do the hard part – make sure intrinsic aspects are maximized.

 

Ron Crabtree

Ron Crabtree, President of MetaOps, Inc., is an organizational transformation coach/trainer, operational excellence (OpEx) adjunct facilitator at Villanova University, Lean and Six Sigma (LSS) speaker, author and thought leader in business process improvement/re-engineering (BPI/BPR). He is a consultant to private industry and government agencies in supply chain management, design of experiments (DOE), statistical process control (SPC), advanced quality systems (AQS), program evaluation review technique (PERT), enterprise resource planning (ERP), demand flow, theory of constraints, organizational change management, and value stream/process mapping and management. Ron has a BA in Management and Organizational Development, is a Master LSS Black Belt, and is Certified in Production and Inventory Management (CPIM), Integrated Resource Management (CIRM), and Supply Chain Professional (CSCP) by American Production and Inventory Control Society (APICS). If you are an executive and would like to chat with Ron about anything related to business process improvement and operational excellence, please get on his calendar here: http://bit.ly/ExecutiveChat

Recent Posts

November 18, 2021
5 Reasons Why Your Organization Should Embrace Digital Transformation

Digital transformation at the enterprise level is the dance between the art of the practical and the possible. It's best approached with a hands-on strategy in helping organizations come up with what they can do at present to attain their goals.  Digital transformation is a whole set of different tools, applications, and technologies that businesses […]

Read More
November 17, 2021
5 Reasons Why Organizations Find It Hard to Go Digital

Until 2021, only 15 percent of organizations had prioritized digital transformation, according to Forrester. These are low numbers, given that most companies and businesses were forced to shift online due to the pandemic. The remaining 85 percent of organizations are working extra hard to keep up with the numerous digital transitions, with little effect. Is […]

Read More
November 16, 2021
Operational Excellence: 3 Proven Ideas that Will Transform Your Operations

Your manufacturing business continually strives to maintain profitability, stay ahead of the competition, and keep pace with technological changes. In addition, achieving and maintaining operational excellence is a significant goal of your company's success. Undoubtedly, this has proven to be a challenge amid a global pandemic as supply chain delays, increased costs, and staffing shortages […]

Read More

Industry Experience

Aerospace
Chemical
Computer/Software
Construction
Consumer Goods
Defense
Energy
Entertainment
Financial Services
Food
Health care
Information Services
Insurance & Retirement
Manufacturing
Automotive
Complex Manufacturing
Media
Pharmaceutical
Pulp and paper
Retail
Steel
Telecommunications
MetaExperts™ a Division of MetaOps
MetaOps Logo Reversed Super Light

Contacts

10343 W RS Avenue, Mattawan, MI 49071, United States
734-425-1455
experts@metaexperts.com

©2021 All rights reserved, MetaOps, Inc.

Sitemap
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram